Everything is Always Broken, and That’s Okay

Beyond “competition,” “efficiency” and “innovation,” interop delivers self-determination.

Image from Theophilus Brown’s 1915 patent for a manure spreader (USP#1139482)

I am recuperating from hip-replacement surgery and while that often means I can’t concentrate enough to work, it also means I have long, uninterrupted periods to carry on correspondence, such as the paragraphs below, from my overdue reply to a left-wing economist with whom I’ve been discussing the case for interoperability. In our previous round, my correspondent had suggested that interop wasn’t necessarily good, and that even profitable interop could be bad for all of us — do we really need 50 nearly identical inks on Amazon that can all work with our printer? How can anyone make a “good” choice in that environment? My response is below.

Continue reading "Everything is Always Broken, and That’s Okay"

Pluralistic: 24 Aug 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 24 Aug 2021"

Pluralistic: 07 Aug 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 07 Aug 2021"

Pluralistic: 01 Aug 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 01 Aug 2021"

Pluralistic: 14 Jul 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 14 Jul 2021"

Pluralistic: 07 Jul 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 07 Jul 2021"

Pluralistic: 22 Jun 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 22 Jun 2021"

Pluralistic: 21 Jun 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 21 Jun 2021"

The EU, Tech Trustbusting, and Trade Wars

There’s a difference between protectionism and political will

The EU flag superimposed over a Matrix “code waterfall” effect; in the center of the ring of stars is a vintage newspaper caricature of Roosevelt as a trustbuster, swinging his “big stick.”

Competition regulators in the EU, the UK and the US are all looking hard at concentration in the tech sector, and well they should: an industry that was once hailed for its dynamism — for being a sector where yesterday’s world-spanning titans are sold for parts to companies that were mere napkin doodles a year or two before — has calcified into “a group of five websites, each consisting of screenshots of text from the other four.

The reasons for tech concentration are pretty straightforward. Despite a lot of fatalistic tech exceptionalism about “network effects” leading to inevitable monopolization, the actual means by which tech companies consolidated is actually easy to see in the historical record.

Continue reading "The EU, Tech Trustbusting, and Trade Wars"

Pluralistic: 16 Jun 2021


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 16 Jun 2021"