What is “Peak Indifference?”

A Theory and a Plan for Change.

A silhouette of a shrugging man in front of a wildfire.
( Cameron Strandberg/CC BY 2.0, modified)

Back in 2016, I coined the term “peak indifference” to describe a political phenomenon, when people who have denied an urgent problem begin to self-radicalize, not because of activists or public education, but because the problem has caught up with them, personally.

As I’ve written here, a neat microcosm of peak indifference is smoking: even if you convince yourself that tobacco isn’t that bad for you, if you keep smoking long enough, you will likely come to understand that it is very bad for you, because Stage 4 lung-cancer is convincing in a way that even the most persuasive talk with your family doctor can never be.

Continue reading "What is “Peak Indifference?”"

Pluralistic: 06 Mar 2022


A picture of a grinning skull in a mortarboard. From The Epistasix (1920)/Medical Society of the University of Toronto.

The Epistasix (1920)/Medical Society of the University of Toronto

Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 06 Mar 2022"

Pluralistic: 05 Mar 2022


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 05 Mar 2022"

Pluralistic: 04 Mar 2022


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 04 Mar 2022"

Pluralistic: 01 Mar 2022


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 01 Mar 2022"

Pluralistic: 27 Feb 2022


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 27 Feb 2022"

All (Broadband) Politics Are Local

A Chance for Individuals to Make a Difference.

Farmers and co-op members assisting professional telephone pole installers raise a rural phone pole, with rope and pulleys, 1930s.

“We’re the phone company, we don’t care.” –Lily Tomlin

Even before the lockdown, we all hated our ISPs. Comcast routinely won “worst company in America” polls. AT&T was a trash-fire of endless boondoggles and scandals. Verizon charged you $12/month to rent a modem, and also charged you $12/month to not rent a modem. Everyone hated Frontier for its slow speeds, which were revealed to be the result of the company’s practice of “installing” phone lines by tying them to trees with twine or draping them over shrubs. New York State ordered Charter/Spectrum to leave the state and never come back.

Then the pandemic struck, and terrible internet service became a matter of survival: it was how your kids went to school, how you visited the doctor, how you saw family, how you participated in civics and politics, and, for those of us who were lucky enough to have remote-capable jobs, how you earned your living.

The dismal state of the American telecoms industry, where monopolies divided up the country into non-competing exclusive territories like Pope Alexander VI dividing up the “New World,” suddenly became a lot more important.

Continue reading "All (Broadband) Politics Are Local"

Pluralistic: 24 Feb 2022


Today's links

Continue reading "Pluralistic: 24 Feb 2022"